As it currently stands, there is no consistent and coherent place
for people to post knot test reports within this forum.
I 100% believe that an wholly new and distinct category needs
to be created within this forum - titled "Knot test Reports (and peer review)".
At the moment, it is random and incoherent - exactly where does
a would-be knot tester currently search? The search function of this forum
is not exactly perfect - I just dont see how this will ever develop legs
and turn into something really useful unless a whole new category is created.
So, I guess Dan Lehman is not in favor
of creating a whole new category titled "Knot test reports"?
How many people do we need to make a giant leap forward for mankind and create a new forum topic/category?
You have my outline of a step --if not a giant leap-- forward
above, in which a
thread carries a "sticky"/master OP
listing test reports, and follow-on posts to this thread would
be citations of other reports of possible interest which then
should be added by Modification to the OP master list.
Discussion of any given report(s) would come in separate
threads, and all of this under
Practical Knots I suppose.
But you envision threads that themselves are reports and
which have follow-on posts of review/discussion, and all
of this wants a superstructure above *thread* which would
be a new (sub-)forum, with an obvious title, for recognition.
Oh, I get that (now); but, really, how many posts would actually
come to such a forum? --Dave Richards, Tom Moyer, Yachting
Monthly, etc. test reports will continue to be of interest to us,
and continue to be made on their own terms and put in their
own ways (possibly in a mag.'s print pages un-URLinkable,
but amenable to someone's summarizing-reporting).
Still, as a conspicuous collection of testing discussion of
whatever sort, a concentrated presentation would help
--if we have a critical mass to constitute that. Could it
be a forum-wise "child" forum to
Practical Knots or some
other extant forum? And a new forum could also carry as its
OP a listing as I envisioned, along with guidance on what is
expected or hoped-for in testing & reporting.
I think that it's possible to move thread from current to
new places if need be? --otherwise, there is simple pasting
& replication/duplication to get the posts to the new spot,
should that become the way forward.
--dl*
====
ps : I'm still remiss in fully responding to the Yachting
mag. test report, and others.