You've rehashed this unconvincing plea a number of times.
Speaking for yourself, perhaps; but Xarax & I & I think/thought
Agent_Smith concur in favoring the presentation of the
bowlineas I urge (and as the
sheet bend is presented, note).
That there is such widespread confusion about the knot
is some strong hint that "the way we've always done it"
isn't so good.
I doubt even you tie the bowline in the manner you propose for presentation.
Is there even a single quick-tie video on YouTube of a internal wrist-rotation method?
Laying out a coil or coils ahead of time doesn't count.
This is going stupid. I don't validate my thoughts
by counting YouTube videos (or knots books, for
that matter : where do you think most of the YouTubers
get things from?).
And the clumsy thing that you show above is absurd.
It hardly has the vaunted movement you find so compelling,
doing work with both hands,
having to grip parts together in the right hand
(even with a supporting surface conveniently & artificially
so near!), and then, egadz, seeing this as a recommendation
for a particular wrist movement?
If someone is e.g.
tying in to their harness with a rope
leading out away from their standing/upright body,
they will most surely benefit from forming the knot
if using this sort of quick-tie method from going the
opposite way to the traditional
--i.e., to righthandedly reach with ample tail out
beneath the outgoing SPart (and so they
will be
supporting it and not having to hold it
in place from falling
as is done in your video ca. 10sec.!),
to then quickly *bend* (rather than much rotate)
the right wrist/hand to bring the tail back over
the SPart, and then extend/unbend (still not much
of *rotation* really) the right hand w/some outward
thrust to put in the nipping-turn in the SPart.
Having done this, the SPart --now PROPERLY ORIENTED--
will
rest upon the outgoing eye leg and not
otherwise fall unless supported manually,
and the final tuck (or whatever various bowline finish
one desires) can be put in.
Yes, the trad view hides & confuses.
This video's starting image is a perfect example:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q9NqGd7464UThe way of quick-tying I present above is well faster
& simpler than that traditionally advocated. (There
is also the method of forming an
overhand nooseand noosing the tail into a capsized knot, to which
e.g. Brion Toss took a fancy.) And, yes, I often do
use the method --always, in pref. to trad.--, and
sometimes the "slip-knot" (noose) way (where I
have no idea yet remembered of which insertion
direction begets tail-outside vs. tail-inside versions).
--dl*
====